contact@cait.in

+91 95604 43514

Background Image

SUPREME COURT ISSUES NOTICE ON AMENDED PETITION OF DELHI TRADERS AGAINST DESIGNATED PROTEST SITES; CONGRESS, CJP, AISA AND AAP IMPLEADED AS RESPONDENTS

In a significant development, the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, before a Bench headed by the Hon’ble Chief Justice of India, today permitted the amended writ petition filed by the Kirana Committee, Delhi Iron & Hardware Merchants Association and other trade associations representing traders and commercial establishments across Delhi, and issued formal notice on the amended petition.

The amendment has been allowed in compliance with the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 3 November 2026, whereby the petitioners were asked to implead the specific organisations and political parties associated with the proposed protests in Delhi.

Accordingly, the Indian National Congress, CJP, AISA and the Aam Aadmi Party have now been impleaded as respondents, bringing the principal organisations associated with the proposed protests within the ambit of the ongoing judicial proceedings.

The amended petition specifically challenges the Delhi Police Standing Order notifying Ramlila Maidan as a designated protest site. It seeks appropriate directions from the Hon’ble Supreme Court for relocating protest sites away from densely populated and major commercial areas, particularly Ramlila Maidan, at least until the conclusion of the ongoing festive season.

The petition further seeks a permanent policy framework under which designated protest sites, after the festive season, are located outside the city limits, ensuring that democratic demonstrations can take place without bringing normal commercial, economic and civic activities of the national capital to a standstill.

The petitioners have emphatically clarified that they fully respect and uphold the fundamental right to peaceful protest, which is an integral pillar of democracy. However, the exercise of this right cannot be permitted to cause prolonged and disproportionate disruption to trade, business activities and the livelihoods of millions of people.

Delhi’s commercial ecosystem sustains lakhs of traders, shopkeepers, employees, daily-wage workers, transporters and numerous other sections dependent on the city’s economic activity. Any prolonged obstruction of commercial areas directly affects their right to work, conduct business and earn an honest livelihood.

The petition raises an important constitutional issue concerning the harmonious balance between the fundamental right to peaceful assembly and protest under Article 19(1)(b) and the fundamental right to practise any profession, or to carry on any occupation, trade or business under Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution of India.

The petitioners maintain that no fundamental right can be exercised in a manner that indefinitely undermines or deprives other citizens of their equally valuable constitutional rights. The objective is not to curtail democratic dissent but to ensure that the rights of one section of society do not come at the disproportionate cost of the rights and livelihoods of another.

Senior Advocate Shri Mukul Rohatgi appeared on behalf of the petitioners.

The issuance of formal notice by the Hon’ble Supreme Court marks an important step in the continuing judicial examination of this issue. It brings into focus the need for a balanced, fair and practical mechanism for regulating public demonstrations while safeguarding the economic interests, commercial activities and everyday lives of citizens.

The petitioners remain hopeful that the proceedings will pave the way for a permanent and balanced policy that protects both democratic freedoms and the fundamental right to livelihood.

The matter will now be considered further by the Hon’ble Supreme Court.

Recent